THE
MACH FIVE FILM REVIEW: X-MEN 3
**1/2 Stars [Out of 4]
Most of us who’ve anticipated this movie already know the
plot. If you don’t know it, then read Roger Ebert’s
column
(http://rogerebert.suntimes.com), because I won’t go into
that. The plot aside, let me point out my thoughts on the film.
Within the first ten minutes, I could already tell that the Brian
Singer touch was missing. So many new characters emerge,
that there is no real personal storyline for any of them like we’ve
seen in the other films. Some of the better characters from
the other movies disappear from this one. Nightcrawler, for instance,
is not even seen or mentioned in X3. Why? Cyclops and
Professor X are absent from over 80% of the movie. The ethical struggle,
between Xavier and Magneto, on how to handle
society’s anti mutant prejudice, vanishes. We have to rely
on having seen the last two films to understand the relationship
between Magneto and Xavier, because it doesn’t continue to
develop the way it did in the previous films. I don’t know
where
this new version of Wolverine came from, but it’s not the
same persona we’ve been accustomed to, played by Jackman.
Granted, he still cuts up a bunch of bad guys with his claws, but
there is absolutely no inner struggle about Wolverine’s identity,
or adapting his lone-wolf behavior into an X-MEN team leader. There
is no real animosity or fighting between Wolverine and
Cyclops. There is no further development of the relationship issues
between Rogue and Iceman. Their lack of physical intimacy
forces Rogue to want to be cured of mutation, but this decision
making struggle isn’t developed. We simply watch it happen
in quick stages, because Ratner has way too many characters to throw
into this movie, and doesn’t have time to develop
these storylines. Unfortunately, I just couldn’t feel any
empathy toward this problem like I did in the other films.
Now, if you possess super powers, rigorously train to use your superpowers,
then you should be kicking butt like someone who
has super powers. In the last film, we see the resourceful talents
of Mystique who waltzes into a fortified military complex
full of heavily armed soldiers, and then begins to kick everyone’s
butt, bare handed. In X3, she can hardly get out of a pair of
handcuffs. In X2, we see Magneto fight with extreme ingenuity by
ripping the iron out of a man’s body, or stripping away all
of
the grenade pins attached to a platoon of soldiers. In X3, this
resourcefulness is completely cast aside and replaced with big
visual effects. For example, instead of placing his army on the
tops of cars or platforms and then levitating them from the golden
gate bridge over to Alcatraz (Alcatraz island is the stage for the
final fight between the X-Men and the Brotherhood of Mutants),
Magneto thinks its much easier, and strategically advantageous,
to move the entire golden gate bridge, so that it now stretches
from the land across the water to Alcatraz island. This isn’t
a strategic advantage for his army. In fact, this now allows US
Forces
easy access to attack the rear of Magneto’s army (which ends
up happening). However, this feat is visually cool for us in the
audience to witness, and I’m sure that’s why Ratner
made it happen that way. Iceman, possibly the most kick-ass character
of
the X-MEN team, can’t seem to use his powers to do anything
other than make a few ice walls and throw some snow balls. This
is
the third X-MEN movie! By now, I think its time to see Iceman sliding
on the ice track, or freezing the blood inside people’s
bodies until their tissues rupture (gruesome, isn’t it). But
no, Iceman is the equivalent to a suped up, bi-ped, fire extinguisher.
We watch Colossus, Juggernaut, Angel, Multiple Man, Pyro, and series
of others show a few skills, but not enough for me to
appreciate seeing them on the screen. Of course, the twelve-year-olds
sitting in front of me were eating it up. For me,
though, if you can’t show Colossus getting medieval on bunch
of bad guys, then don’t show him in the movie! Don’t
get my
hopes up. Instead, almost everything is predictable.
Two saving points I will mention: Beast and Storm. Storm finally
gets the credit she deserves. She can fly, for one thing, and
shows more of her extreme agility and combat skills, than in any
of the other movies. Beast is more of an asset to the movie
than I originally thought. At first, I was skeptical about Kelsey
Grammer’s role as the Beast. But I’ve changed my mind.
Beast’s
fight scenes in the movie are extremely cool, and well choreographed,
even if they are brief (nothing compares to the opening
Nightcrawler sequence in X2 however).
Also, good storytelling involves the use of good dialogue. Good
dialogue in a superhero movie is difficult to achieve for an adult
audience. I have yet to see a superhero film with dialogue as well
written as Batman Begins. However the X-men and Spider-man
movies have yielded good results in this area in the past. In this
aspect, I’m disappointed in X3. Every time I heard Wolverine
or
Kitty Pride toss out a cheesy one-liner, I cringed. However those
kids in front of me were eating it up with laughter and
excitement. Thus, while my disappointment grew, the praise exhibited
by the kids in front of me left me outnumbered. That
probably means dollar signs for Ratner. Speaking of dollar signs,
the last twenty minutes of the movie contain a lot of extensive
special effects (an attempt at redemption). To this extent, although
predictable, X3 is very entertaining.
Overall, being a huge comic book fan myself, my opinion is this.
I give X-MEN III a rating of two and half stars (out of four). It
just
can’t compete with the previous two films. If you’re
a comic book fan, go see it in the theater for the sole purpose
of experiencing
the big budget effects and recognizing your favorite characters
on screen. Otherwise save your eight dollars, put it on your Netflix
list, and wait for the release on DVD. Either way, I think you’ll
at least find it entertaining, and visually cool.
C |